Developing. Updates at end of article.
Copycat websites can take different forms. At one end of the scale there’s the content-scraping activity that is used for phishing. At the other end of the scale are websites that piggyback off existing businesses to add value. In some cases it works well. In others it can lead to customer confusion, or worse.
The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) is the state-level US organisation that handles the complex tasks of vehicle and driver registrations. They are organised at state level and their websites are distributed amongst .gov and .com domains.
dmv.org, on the other hand, is a for-profit website owned by Online Guru Inc. in San Diego. This week their organic search visibility was cut by 80%
The IRS is, of course, the Internal Revenue Service, the government organisation charged with handling all matters of tax in the USA, another highly complex task. Their website is at the domain irs.gov.
irs.com, on the other hand, is a for-profit website owned by Remark Media in Las Vegas. This week their organic search visibility was cut by 85%.
We’ve taken a close look at these two domains to see if they have made any technical SEO mistakes and we haven’t found anything obvious. We’re even quite impressed at the long-term strength of the domains and, what appears to be, truly helpful content.
Searching in the USA for common terms such as “tax return form” however, return nothing for irs.com.
Just one week ago, irs.com was at position 7 for this search term.
Google has, at least for now, cut the two domains from their search results. Whatever the reason is, both these domains would have just lost a huge amount of organic traffic. irs.com has lost 83% of their top 10 ranking keywords. Only long-tail, low-traffic keywords remain in the top 10.
History of issues
Interestingly dmv.org has already been through a legal case with the official DMV in California. E-driver, the owning company at the time, was hit with an injunction in 2008. Plaintiffs brought an anti-competition case to trial and dmv.org was forced to display a splash page before customers could use the content. Today, that’s just a site-wide banner explaining that the site is not ‘owned or operated’ by a government agency.
It looks like dmv.org, over time, have built up a great website of information and just taken it too far as a commercial operation.
IRS.com. End of a long story?
For irs.com, also known as USTaxCenter, this could be the end of a long story. In September 2005, Intersearch paid $12.9 million for the domain name and immediately attracted attention from lawmakers wanting to clamp down on domains that were similar to official government agencies. The domain was eventually acquired by Remark Holdings, the Las Vegas company that also runs banks.com (VI 0.01) bikini.com (VI 0.16) sharecare.com (VI 1.926) and vegas.com (VI 10.29) along with Kankan, a social media and AI operation.
Just weeks ago, Remark Media (part of Remark Holdings) announced an expansion project for IRS.com. “Our website now offers a robust platform for self-directed tax preparation.” announced CEO Kai-Shing Tao in a press release. The following ‘forward looking’ statement is also taken from the press release.
“The USTaxCenter attracts a large volume of organic and direct traffic, thanks in part to its strong URL.”Press release.
What happens next?
You can be sure that Remark Media and Online Guru won’t sit back and let this happen without a fight and we wouldn’t be surprised to see this hit the main news channels as the story unfolds. Is there a government action behind this? Will the two domains be able to recover? Do the two companies even know this has happened?
Yes, there could be a technical explanation that we’ve missed so we advise caution. It is possible that the content inside the pages has been made invisible to Googlebots. But for
two three companies, both running ‘ghost-like’ US government-related websites, to see the same pattern seems like too much of a co-incidence to us. ‘On hold, pending investigation’ seems like a more likely answer.
Whatever your intentions, if people come to you thinking you’re the real thing and walk away with bad service and the knowledge that you’re not the real thing, you’re going to get bad feedback. The bad feedback is going to lead to bad reviews and will damage the brand, leading, at the very least, to potentially bad signals in Google search. Be careful with unofficial piggyback and ghost-like web operations.
12th Feb 22:22 – medicare.com, an ehealth inc. domain has also been hit. (Thx Tony Spencer) The desktop loss was similar at 83%. Note that the losses on mobile search are greater. In this case 95%. From their website:
“eHealthInsurance Services, Inc. acquired Medicare.com from MedX in March 2014. “
16 March 2019. irs.com are still removed from Google search in the USA. Interestingly we haven’t see any news about their problems, which could be financial given the huge drop in important Google visibility.