No. A website which is not optimised for mobile devices does not receive minus points by Google and will also catch no penalty. It is wrong to speak of a Google Penalty in the context of the Mobile Friendly Update.
No penalty for un-optimised pages
Google has made it clear that with the new update the visibility of individual mobile friendly pages should rise. This only affects Google’s mobile search results, which are shown for search requests using a smartphone. The desktop search results will not be affected by the Google update in any way.
We’re boosting the ranking of mobile-friendly pages on mobile search results.– Google Webmaster Central Blog
This should make it clear that there is neither an active discrimination nor any form of algorithmic penalty at work. Google will not penalise a website. If a website does not meet all the criteria for a mobile friendly use but still offers good, high-quality content, then this website will continue to rank and will still be found using a smartphone search.
Non-mobile-friendly sites won’t disappear from mobile Search results – they may still rank high if they hold great content the user wants.– Google Inside Search Blog
Mobile friendly pages receive a ranking boost
Google marks the mobile friendliness of a search result rather discretely using a label in front of the meta description. Any URL optimised for smartphone users can receive preferential treatment and a ranking boost. This occurs when, for example, two pages offer good content at the same quality level on a subject, but with only one of them being optimised for the needs of mobile searchers. In this case, the algorithm is supposed to ensure that the page optimised for mobile devices is treated favorably – ranking it higher.
We published our initial findings and analysis of the mobile update in a blog post, summarising the effects of the algorithm update.
Misleading reports in the press
The assumption that Google would punish entire websites, if they were not optimised for smartphones by the deadline of the 21st of April 2015, is due to misleading and false reports in the press.
The following excerpts, which are circulated through the media and several articles are wrong or leave room for false conclusions:
- The mobile friendly update only degrades pages that don’t offer a mobile version of their website.
- Anyone who […] isn’t prepared will very likely be confronted with considerable penalties